Guess what came in the mail yesterday at my house! My property tax bill - woohoo! In actuality, this is the single most expensive bill that I get every year (twice), and it makes a REAL dent in my budget when I pay it. At least this one is the smaller of the two bills, but it's still a ton!
For many homeowners, property taxes aren’t just a line item on the budget—they’re one of the most frustrating annual expenses. If you’ve ever felt like your local government is guessing the value of your house, or you’ve watched your tax bill climb while neighboring houses pay less, you’re not alone. Thankfully, throughout the U.S., you have the right to challenge your property tax assessment through a formal appeals process, and doing so can mean hundreds or even thousands in savings every year.
I’ve personally appealed my property taxes for more than a decade here in Cook County, Illinois—sometimes with great success, sometimes with… well, “better luck next year.” Every time, I’ve learned more about how the system works, when to DIY, and when it’s worth considering professional help. The process is a little different in every state and county, but the general strategies and steps remain pretty consistent:
Step 1: Understand How Property Taxes Are Assessed
- Every year (or few years), your local government assesses your property’s value—often through your county assessor’s office—and calculates your property taxes based on that figure. Your tax bill = assessed value x local tax rate.
- But assessments can be inaccurate or based on market conditions that don’t reflect the reality of your neighborhood. Maybe the assessor missed recent repairs, didn’t account for a nearby highway, or just got the comps wrong.
- Your right: You can file an appeal, asking them to review (and hopefully lower) the assessed value.
Step 2: Know Your Appeal Options
- Most counties offer one or more “windows”—specific time periods each year—to file an appeal online, by mail, or in person. In my situation here in Cook County, Illinois, I get two separate opportunities:
- The Cook County Assessor’s Office (https://www.cookcountyassessoril.gov/appeals)
- The Cook County Board of Review (https://www.cookcountyboardofreview.com/)
- Each has its own deadlines, so watch those windows closely—they usually stick to a reliable schedule year after year, but they’re not simultaneous! I always put the dates in my calendar just to stay ahead.
Step 3: Gather Evidence (Comparable Properties Are Key!)
- The heart of a successful appeal is “comparables”—properties in your area close in size, age, and style to yours, but assessed at a lower value. Your goal: show that yours is over-assessed versus what’s typical.
- How to find comparables:
- Check your assessor’s website or property records database for recent assessments in your neighborhood.
- Use online real estate sites (Zillow, Realtor.com) for sale prices, but focus on the assessed values, not just listings.
- Look for houses with similar lot sizes, bedrooms, square footage, age, and condition.
- Note differences that affect value (busy street, flood zone, major repairs needed, etc.).
- The first year you do this, it can take an hour or two. After that, you’ll get the hang of it and be able to complete future appeals in as little as 10–15 minutes each—especially if you do your neighbors’ or relatives’ appeals, as I do for my mom and sister. Organization is key: keep notes, favorite links, and a template appeal letter handy!
Step 4: Submit Your Appeal
- Every county is different, but the best systems let you submit online. You’ll need:
- The address and parcel number of your property
- Your supporting evidence, like three to six comparables (addresses, assessed values)
- A simple explanation of why you believe your assessment is too high
- Documentation, if available (photos, appraisals, repair receipts)
- In Cook County, you log in, fill out the form, attach comps, and submit. You’ll get a confirmation and can monitor the status online.
Step 5: Wait, Watch, and React
- It can take several weeks (or months) for a decision. My own county seems to either accept almost everyone’s appeal, or almost no one’s—sometimes based on broader market or political considerations, not just your evidence.
- Since COVID hit, the landscape has shifted: property taxes were frozen, postponed, or reduced for many, so post-COVID increases have been steep. Appeals have gotten harder to win, and acceptance rates have dropped. If you go several years without success, don’t take it personally—it’s not just you.
Step 6: Consider Professional Help
- If you’ve got a string of rejected appeals and neighbors are resorting to lawyers, it might be time to call in the pros. I get a flood of postcards and letters every year around appeals time from attorneys who do nothing but property tax appeals. Their pitch is simple: “No win, no fee.” If they save you $500 and their cut is $250, you still keep $250 you wouldn’t have had.
- It may sting to give up a share of the savings, but professionals know the ins, outs, and technical traps that can cause repeated rejections. Maybe there’s something you’ve missed, or they’ll spot an error you wouldn’t have noticed.
- Success rates change year-to-year. Before COVID, I found appealing was much easier—far fewer folks tried, and there weren’t as many lawyers in the game, so I could find those “golden comp” properties that truly didn’t align with mine. Now, more people appeal, attorneys crowd the market, and results are harder to achieve solo.
Step 7: Special Notes for Other U.S. Counties
- If you’re outside Cook County, your process will look similar—check your local assessor and board of review’s websites for deadlines, forms, and policy details. In some states:
- Appeals are only allowed once per cycle or require a fee.
- You can sometimes attend hearings and provide live testimony.
- In others, you can work with a local tax professional, agent, or lawyer.
- Always check:
- Deadlines (mark your calendar for next year if you miss!)
- Required evidence (some counties want recent sales, some want assessed values, some want both)
- Accepted methods (online, mail, or in-person appointments)
Tips and Tricks From a Seasoned Appealer
- Document everything. Save screenshots and printouts of comparables.
- Start early. Appeal windows open and close fast.
- Work in batches. Once you’ve done one, helping relatives or neighbors goes much faster.
- Don’t get discouraged. Even if you miss out one year, next year’s comps may be better.
When to Sell, and When to Stay Put
- If taxes keep climbing, major repairs loom, or you feel squeezed year after year, sometimes the math points to selling your home and buying in a less expensive area. But before that, always try the appeal process—not only for savings, but for a sense of empowerment. You don’t have to accept your bill at face value! My family often complains about "Crook County" taxes, and have strongly considered moving, but we always end up staying put. Some day, I will be priced out of this area, sadly. Property taxes are a HUGE expense!
Final Thoughts: You Don’t Have to Pay More Than Your Fair Share
Appealing property taxes isn’t just for number crunchers or legal eagles—it’s something every homeowner can and should try. Whether you’re in Cook County or anywhere in the U.S., understanding the appeal process, gathering your comparable evidence, and staying organized can mean hundreds—even thousands—in annual savings. And if your efforts stall, don’t hesitate to call in the professionals. Saving $500 and sharing it with your lawyer is a win compared to paying inflated taxes for years.
So, take a Saturday afternoon, check your local assessor’s site, learn the deadlines, and file an appeal or two. Trust me: even if you only win some years, it makes a huge difference over time. Have tips, tales, or questions about the process? Pop them in the comments—let’s help each other pay only what’s fair, and keep a little more in our pockets for what matters most.
Comments
Post a Comment